Lost.
if you couldn’t tell, there will be spoilers.
I, like many people, tuned in weekly to watch the saga continue on the mysterious island in Lost. My husband hadn’t seen the show up until just last year, when we watched seasons 1 through 5, episode after episode, in order to get caught up for when season 6 came on. Now that the show has ended and the movie-length finale over, I thought I would express some of my final thoughts, as well as ask the questions that were never answered.
How it ended: The idea of purgatory.
The ending pretty much confirmed for me what I had thought to be the case since season 1: they were dead and this was purgatory. But it isn’t as simple as that as the finale explains this alternate world, the world where Desmond was relinking everyone together, was where they were all waiting to be reunited so they could move on together. Which, to me, indicated the alternate world was the purgatory in which everyone waited. But there is plenty of evidence to support the island was a part of purgatory as well:
-No one could leave the island. When Desmond tried in Season 2 to leave with the sailboat he ended up coming back again, describing the island as being “stuck in a snowglobe.”
-No one from the outside could find the island.
-The Others were choosing people to kidnap and, when confronted on the very few occasions, had explained that the people they were taking were pure, and the rest of the plane crashed lot were not. (which could indicate the “pure” were moving on to heaven and out of purgatory).
-Locke could walk again and Rose was no longer “dying” of cancer.
-Women could not conceive on the island, which makes sense given you cannot create life in purgatory. Women who were pregnant when they arrived could still give birth, however. If the island was purgatory and they were dead, it would follow that their unborn children were dead as well, and the souls trapped on the island along with them (these children were also targets of abduction by the Others. Aaron, Claire’s baby and Sun). This remains true with both the mother of Jacob and the Man in Black as well as Russou, who gave birth to Alex.
-Characters who had led bad lives, and made bad decisions were not present at the end when Christian Shepard led everyone out of the church and into the light. This included Michael, Ecko, Anna Lucia, and Ben Linus. Leading one to assume those that were present had proven themselves enough to move on to heaven.
-The Dharma Initiative is a metaphor. In eastern religions such as Hinduism and Buddhism, Dharma is the trials and steps one must take in order to reach nirvana, or enlightenment. In the show the entire Initiative, the tests that were undertaken by the original Initiative as well as the challenges the Dharma stations posed to those stranded on the island, serve as a metaphorical test, combining the philosophies of the eastern religions along with those of the Christian faith and the idea of purgatory, that the characters must undergo in order to move on.
-The Egyptian statue holding the ankh is a common symbol in Egyptian mythology. The ankh is the symbol for eternal life, and is commonly seen in the hands of deities associated with the afterlife.
But when did they die?
The major question that comes to mind when dealing with the theme of purgatory is “when did they die?” The above points I made would indicate that the plane crash in the very first episode was the point in which they all died and entered purgatory (the island). However, if this was the case then how is Ben Linus able to travel to and from the island? How was the island able to be moved using the turning wheel and the light? When new people arrived to the island was it to be assumed they were already dead?
The second spot in which they could’ve died could have been when Juliette set the bomb off in the soon-to-be-built Dharma station. She told Sawyer just before she died that “it worked.” It was from this point in the story that the alternate world story started. You could assume that, at the explosion, everyone on the island died and both the island and the alternate world were two different levels of purgatory.
The third theory I have on when they died is that ONLY the alternate world is purgatory, and they all died individually: either whilst on the island, or off the island, or simply due to natural causes long after the island. What indicates this for me is the last ten minutes of the finale. Hurley is about to enter the church and exchanges a few words with Ben Linus. Ben states he will not be joining them inside the church, that he wasn’t ready yet (perhaps he is due to spend a longer time in purgatory due to his life). Hurley tells him he “was a great number 2″ and Ben replies that Hurley was “a great number 1″ (Star Trek reference, by the way.) This would indicate that they both lived out their duties on the island together, Hurley protecting it and Ben acting as his second in command, further supporting that ONLY the alternate world is representative of purgatory.
The last ten minutes.
I once asked a pastor if people remain married when they die and go to heaven. The response I got was that the souls of people in heaven do not remember such connections to others, and in a way “forget.” This was the case of characters in Lost, as they needed Desmond to reconnect them in the alternate world. They all met up in the church and Christian Shepard led them into the light and, presumably, into heaven. I didn’t quite understand why Claire’s baby Aaron was present as a baby (supporting they died in the initial plane crash) and why Penny was there as well (supporting that the island was, in no way, purgatory).
All in all, I was satisfied with the ending, I thought it confirmed alot of what I had expected throughout the series. But they left alot of things unanswered.
W…..T…..F….???
Here are some burning questions I wanted resolved but were left unanswered:
-What was the deal with Walt? Walt was painted in the first couple seasons as being “special.” This was something that was shown both in his life before the island when he lived with his step father after the death of his mother, and in his time on the island when he was wanted by the Others for how “special” he is. In what way was he special? How was he able to appear to people in spectral form, both to Locke and to Shannon (which led to her death)? And why was he completely written off the show after he was off the island (save for a few, rare, meaningless appearances)?
-What was the significance of the numbers? 4 8 15 16 23 42. The only thing I can think of is that they corresponded to the plane seats of the characters who would become candidates to replace Jacob. The only evidence I have of this is that we know Jack sat in 42F, as he revealed this when drinking with Anna Lucia in the Sydney airport bar, and that there are 6 numbers… the same numbers of candidates. But why enter them into the computer? Perhaps its a metaphor for faith? Press them because you are told you must, with no other proof?
-What was the deal with the polar bears? Seriously.
-How did a simple electromagnetic barrier prevent the Smoke Monster, assumed to be the devil, from entering various areas on the island?
-What was Richard’s role?
-How could Desmond move between points in time (as he was coached on by Faraday), predict deaths, and link everyone together in the alternate world?
-How could Charles Widmore find the island?
-Who were those people sent on the second plane crash to protect Jacob?
The sad thing is, we may never know.
Share on Facebook




































